top of page

No Permit on File for the Porch Room: A North Fort Myers Addition

Michael D. Stewart, P.E.
10 hours ago
4 min read

This summer a homeowner in North Fort Myers sent us an email about a problem with his house. His house is a one-story concrete block home built in 1978, on a rural lot with a well and a septic system. He reported that the original porch had been expanded and closed in as a studio apartment. In his words, "the foundation was not reinforced and the back of the room is now sinking."

Cover photo from our September site visit. Photo from the actual job, not AI or a stock image.

He wanted a full two-bedroom, two-bath addition with a den in its place. With that first email he sent the survey, the elevation certificate (a surveyor's form that records how high the house sits), the footprint from the property appraiser and a sketch of what he had in mind. That is a good start.

No permit was on file for the porch room

The owner told us the porch work had been done without permits. He also said the previous owner did not leave behind any drawings or permit papers, and that "some" of the work on the property was never formally documented.

Our office asked Lee County for its records on the property. The answer came back short. The County had four records for the whole property: a 2017 reroof from shingles to metal, a well permit from 1994, and two older County files that were not building permits. None of the four was a building permit for a structure on the property. There were no plans on file for the porch room.

The flood paperwork was thin too. The house sits in flood zone AE (a high-risk flood area on FEMA's maps), with part of the lot in the regulatory floodway (the channel area set aside to carry floodwater). The County had no elevation certificate on file. County staff noted that the house is "pre-FIRM," meaning it was built before the flood maps, and that the County did not begin requiring elevation certificates until it joined the federal flood insurance program in 1984. The certificate a surveyor prepared in 2022 was the one we worked from.

A new addition in its place

Our office did not certify the existing porch room, and the permit set shows it removed. In its place goes a new two-bedroom, two-bath addition with a den.

We visited the house in September and took photos. In October the owner approved the layout and told us he was ready to proceed. The addition matches the house: concrete block with stucco and a metal roof, with 9-foot ceilings and impact-rated windows (built to resist wind-blown debris). The set also carries an electrical plan for the addition and the Florida energy form.

On October 19 we delivered the signed and sealed (stamped by the engineer) 17-sheet permit set and the signed energy form, ready for the owner to submit to Lee County. If the County sends plan-review comments, we answer them until the permit is approved. That is part of the job.

What this means if it is your house

Older homes sometimes have rooms that were added or closed in without a permit. An unpermitted room can come up when you want to add on, sell, or deal with an insurance or flood question.

A room with no permit on file is a question mark even when it looks fine, because there are no approved drawings showing how it was built. The first step is finding out what is actually on file.

What to do

  1. Ask the County what it has. Your building department can tell you which permits exist for your property. If the room you are worried about is not on the list, ask whether anything on record covers it.

  2. Do not lean on an old room that is moving. If a closed-in porch is sinking or cracking, have an engineer look at it before you build anything new against it or on top of it.

  3. Gather what you have. A current survey, an elevation certificate, the property appraiser's footprint and a rough sketch of what you want can help a design get started.

  4. Ask the flood questions early. In a flood zone, ask about the FEMA 50% rule (the substantial improvement rule, which looks at the cost of the work against the value of the house) before the layout is final. The answer can change what you are allowed to build.

  5. Check the other buildings too. If one room was never permitted, ask about the sheds, shops and barns on the same lot. That can come up in a permit application.

  6. Mind the code date. A complete permit application filed before December 31, 2026 is reviewed under the Florida Building Code 8th Edition (2023). One filed on or after that date falls under the 9th Edition (2026). If you are close to that line, talk with your designer about which one your set should be drawn to.

If you are planning an addition, our home addition structural engineering page covers how we work, and our Fort Myers structural engineer page covers the area we serve around North Fort Myers.

FAQ

I just found out a room on my house was never permitted. What should I do first?Ask your building department for the permit history on your property, so you know what is and is not on file. Then call an engineer before you change anything, especially if the room is settling or cracking.

Can an unpermitted room just be permitted as it is?An existing room would have to be evaluated and certified before it could be kept. In this case the owner chose to remove the room and have a new addition designed in its place, to be submitted for a permit.

My house is in a flood zone. Does that change an addition?It can. Your elevation certificate, your flood zone and the FEMA 50% rule can all affect what you are allowed to build. Find those answers before the layout is final, not after.

Do I need a soils report for an addition?A soils report is a geotechnical engineer's study of the ground under the building. When part of the house is reported to be settling, ask your engineer whether one makes sense for your lot before the foundation is designed.

If you have a closed-in porch or an old room you are not sure about, call Michael D. Stewart, P.E. at 239.292.7670 or contact us.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page